4. The Undertaker (3-1)
You would think that a guy whose entire persona has become tied to WrestleMania would have a slew of main events under his belt, but you’d be wrong.
The Undertaker, despite wrestling 25 Mania matches, has only main-evented four of them. As you’d expect with a 23-2 record, he’s done quite well, losing only one Mania main event: last year to Roman Reigns in a deeply disappointing match.
Taker has beaten Psycho Sid, Edge and Shawn Michaels, winning two world titles and retiring Mr. WrestleMania. Those accomplishments alone merit high placement on this list.
His loss to Reigns was a confusing and disappointing moment, but we’ll give the Deadman the benefit of the doubt due to his phenomenal career and track record.